Reframing “Disadvantaged”: A Justice Lens for Education

“It’s quite a sticky label and it can make you feel doomed to a certain fate” (Taylor 2022) Some words become so embedded in our educational narratives that we risk stopping being able to hear them. Disadvantaged has recently emerged into one of those words. It appears so frequently, embedded in our policy documents, funding…

“It’s quite a sticky label and it can make you feel doomed to a certain fate”

(Taylor 2022)

Some words become so embedded in our educational narratives that we risk stopping being able to hear them. Disadvantaged has recently emerged into one of those words. It appears so frequently, embedded in our policy documents, funding guidance, school improvement plans and discussions, that it can seem like just another category or label, rather than something that risks shaping how we see or perceive our children and young people.

In 2022, Olivia Taylor argued in her viral speech ‘Don’t Call Me Disadvantaged ‘, labels like this are never neutral. They shape how children are seen and spoken about, and most significantly how they come to see themselves. Deficit terms can (and often do) obscure the structural inequalities that shape young people’s lives, reinforcing the truth that children are not differently able but differently experienced, their outcomes shaped far more by the opportunities, resources and conditions around them than by any inherent limitation.

Within our education systems, where identity, confidence and belonging are deeply intertwined, this matters more than we often acknowledge.

What the label quietly implies

“I think thinking of a child as “disadvantaged” treats them like they are lacking somewhat in themselves. And that it’s like a permanent state of being”

(Taylor 2022)

The difficulty with the term disadvantaged is not that it identifies children who face structural barriers, those barriers are real and well‑documented. The difficulty is that the label itself subtly positions the deficit within the child or young person. It suggests that something about them, or their family, or their community is lacking. Deficit language can narrow teacher expectations and shape the way children’s behaviour and potential are interpreted. Gillborn’s (2008) analysis of educational categorisation delves deeper, arguing that seemingly neutral labels often obscure the deeper racialised and classed structures that produce inequity in the first instance.

Furthermore, Ladson‑Billings’ (2006) framing of educational debt is particularly poignant here. What we often describe as ‘gaps’ are not natural occurrences but the cumulative result of historical, political and economic decisions. When we use the word disadvantaged, we risk telling a story about our children and young people, that often masks this truth.

Noticing the Power of Our Words

“… So, if I don’t like the word “disadvantaged” what do I use? I personally use the word “underserved”. Which points the emphasis back onto the society to help young people from challenging backgrounds.”

(Taylor 2022)

Shifting to the term ‘underserved’ can be not onlypowerful but empowering. It redirects our attention away from the child and toward the systems around them. It acknowledges that inequity is not an inherent trait but a consequence of how opportunity is distributed. This reframing aligns with the notion of culturally relevant pedagogy, which challenges us to resist deficit thinking and recognise the cultural wealth children bring. It resonates with the belief that education is a site where identity and power are negotiated, not a neutral landscape, echoing Boaler’s (2016) research, within mathematics education, showing how fixed notions of ability disproportionately harm those already marginalised.

Seen through this lens, underserved becomes a more accurate and more ethical description. It invites us to ask not, “What is wrong with this child?” but “How have our systems failed to serve them well?”

Viewing curriculum as a lived experience

“Rather than a young person having to work to overcome “disadvantage”, a society must learn how to serve them”

 (Taylor 2022)

The curriculum is often perceived as objective, untouched by social forces, but children’s experiences of this tell a different story. Research tells us that access to high‑quality teaching is uneven, that teacher expectations can reproduce social inequalities, and that curriculum choices can and do either affirm or marginalise children’s identities. These are not small details. They shape whether a child experiences their education as a place of belonging or exclusion. At a time when national curriculum reviews are underway within our four nations, this matters even more: the decisions made now about what counts as important, and whose knowledge is centred, will shape the opportunities available to children and young people for years to come.

Ultimately, when we describe a child as disadvantaged, the structural forces shaping their experiences can slip out of our sights. However, when we describe them as underserved, those forces come back into view; and, hopefully, so does our responsibility and ambition to change and challenge them.

Language as a lever for justice

“Words really do have power.”

(Taylor 2022)

Language is at the heart of this debate.

It is a lever, which shapes our understanding and ultimately, influences the questions we ask, the assumptions we make and the decisions we then take.

As Taylor drew our attention to- young people notice the labels adults use. They feel the weight of them, understand what is being implied and push back. This should not be mistaken as a rejection of support, but because they reject being defined by deficit.

Reframing our language is not about softening the edges. It is about telling the truth, positioning and naming the inequity where it lives, in our systems, not in our children and young people.

If we want classrooms where every child and young people feel they belong, where their identity is affirmed, their agency recognised and their potential seen, then we must begin with the words we choose to represent them.

The term disadvantaged tells a story about them.

The term underserved tells a story about the systems they exist within.

Only one of those stories leads us toward justice.

Leave a Reply