Is agency becoming a lost word of childhood?

Agency, in the context of early childhood, is founded upon children being empowered to take their learning into their own hands. It is an ambition founded in multiple theories, from Montessori to Reggio Emilio, yet what unites these perspectives is the narrative around how we consider how we situate our children as central actors in…

Agency, in the context of early childhood, is founded upon children being empowered to take their learning into their own hands. It is an ambition founded in multiple theories, from Montessori to Reggio Emilio, yet what unites these perspectives is the narrative around how we consider how we situate our children as central actors in their learning journey.  The environment is often a pivotal aspect of this, with it being suggested that agency arises from the interaction between enabling environments.

However, opportunities for children’s agency in classroom environments can be scarce, a consequence of tight teacher control through a focus on strict learning objectives and standards (Le Courtois, 2022). Our early years classrooms are at risk of being stripped of places for play in lieu of a perceived need for school readiness. There is also a huge disparity of what these environments should or could look like.

The revised Early Years framework (DfE 2024) advocates that children must have access to an outdoor environment, however there is little guidance regarding either the quality of the environment or how children experience this in action. The notion of ‘agency’ is not mentioned in this document, and was not recorded in the government publication, Development Matters (DfE 2023). However, Birth to 5 Matters  (Early years Coalition, 2021), makes several references to agency. It advocates that inclusive provision:

“accepts and understands children for who they are, including their capabilities to sense, feel, and their agency to choose the things they like and enjoy doing, as well as identifying the things that they do not like or enjoy” (p.9)

We recently designed a Close to Practice (see BERA 2019) project which explores how children in the Early Years and Foundation Setting (EYFS) experience agency within an outdoors setting. This project challenges current EYFS practice to consider the quality of its outdoor provision and considers the value of child voice within research practices. It is the ambition of this project to explore how to enhance an early years outdoor provision to become an enabling environment where children experience autonomy and develop confidence in their own agency.

This project is in its early infancy, but already there is some revealing evidence regarding the state of play of children’s agency. Just like the absence of this word in our most recent policy document, it appeared in our initial findings that children are struggling to demonstrate their agency. Whilst observing their play in action and listening to their voice, often what was revealed was adult influence.

A common thread within both year groups was that children expressed a dislike of areas that were dirty or had the potential to make them dirty or wet:

“I don’t like it when I get dirty…When I get wet.”

“Because every time I want to chalk I don’t want chalk on my hands.”

There was a sense that children had picked up on negative messages from adults or parents about the potential of becoming wet or dirty in areas of sensory play like the mud kitchen and water areas and therefore avoided them in their free choice play. Along a similar line was the idea of certain areas being considered unsafe:

“I don’t want to fall off and hurt myself.”

“I don’t like playing on the big slide. Because I might fall.”

The idea of getting hurt, or perhaps memories of being hurt in a certain area, seemed to be a powerful motivator in a dislike of a space. Adult voice has a powerful role in either supporting children in risky play or dissuading children from the area entirely, despite risky play being an important part of a child’s development. Perhaps the key here is a child’s agency. Agency to explore and discover for themselves how far is safe, how can they approach a play space in a way that feels safe for them but also challenging.

The final thread of commonality was the notion of adult roles within play. The children enjoyed reflecting adult themes within their play:

“I like playing with that family think. Like families there. There were seats there.”

“I like the house. I like to play sister and grown-ups”

“I do like water. Cooking soup and rice”

Most of the children expressed an enjoyment of play which reflected the everyday activities of adults: role playing families, driving cars, cooking. Role play and risky places are both powerful learning experiences and in turn help children to make sense of the world around them.

Just like the disappearance of the word ‘agency’ from our most recent Early Years Framework, it appeared that our children had lost this capacity from their play and thus early childhood experiences.

The interviews that have taken place with these children are vital for our next steps. We have designed our next research cycle to act upon their feedback. It is our hope that by listening and acting on children’s voices, such negotiation will afford our children the possibility to experience agency because their voice and influence are valued.

Co Authored as part of a Close-to-Practice project with Roanne Torr

Response to “Is agency becoming a lost word of childhood?”

  1. Anne Gayfer

    An interesting piece. I know it’s not directly your sphere, but wh

Leave a Reply