Fluency? Reasoning? Problem-solving? Sorry, what was the question?

Things I wish I could go back and tell my NQT-self. A journey of understanding what teaching for mastery really means and how this enables every child to become a mathematician. A matter of inclusion, as well as mathematics.

Learning mathematics is about looking at what you thought you understood and seeing that there’s deeper mystery there than you realised.

DAN FINKEL

The end of my ITT saw the implementation of the new primary curriculum. I vividly remember the chaos which erupted across the schools I was training in, as they tried to piece together what these changes would mean for the teaching and learning of their children. At this time, it became clear to me that the most talked-about pedagogical reform laid inside the pages of the new primary maths curriculum. It was one that had been sculpted from the findings from years of research and imported best practice from South-East Asia. 

Many years later, we are all fiercely familiar with our maths curriculum’s core aims: fluency, reasoning, and problem-solving. Underpinning these aims is the term coined as ’teaching for mastery’, a term I find myself regularly ranting and raving about, as my school’s maths subject lead. For me, the term ‘teaching for mastery’ resonates with the belief that every child can succeed in mathematics, that all children are destined to be mathematicians. 

It is a wonderful idea, that if we teach to mastery, we create inclusive maths lessons inside classrooms that become the context for many mathematical adventures (see the bear hunt picture-probably my favourite analogy!)…

However, what is the reality? 

I absolutely do not think I have the answer, (sorry, feel free to abandon the blog now!) What I do have are my own reflections to unpick, regarding what my own maths practice has looked like. This is alongside the privilege of having worked closely with our local maths hub, meaning I have the added advantage of having been able to observe and reflect upon the practice of others. 

I am going to go right back to the maths curriculum’s core aims: fluency, reasoning and problem-solving, as I believe my story begins here. Time and time again, I have heard and noticed the terms fluency, reasoning and problem-solving used to define progression across maths lessons. I even recall how in some cases, these become tools to differentiate a ‘task’ or create lesson progression! 

I have 100% been guilty as charged. 

In my NQT year, I remember being presented with documents headed: fluency, reasoning and problem-solving. I would plan lessons on fluency, lessons on reasoning and then separate problem solving ‘challenges’ for those with a GDS prediction slapped on their end of year targets. I was told that this was ‘mastery’… that mastery was about creating ‘masters’ and that these ‘masters’ were children who were ‘clever’ or ‘gifted’ and simply warranted that title. This, of course, meant that inside my classroom, there were children in my class who were not presented the opportunity to become a ‘master’; their mathematical bear hunt was different, my maths lessons albeit subconsciously, segregated them…

So what changed? I was lucky enough to become part of a Teacher Research Group (TRG) through our local maths hub. Here I not only discovered (well was directed to really…) but began to really understand the Teaching for Mastery 5 Big Ideas. The Teaching for Mastery 5 Big Ideas exist to inform (based on research) what teaching for mastery means in practice; however, the NCETM itself admits that these ideas are brought to life during daily maths teaching. That was the beauty with the TRG. I began to observe, reflect upon and discuss what these ‘big ideas’ looked like in real life. I want to point out that these were not lesson observations in the way you may have experienced. They were very much conversations about learning, about the ‘big ideas’ we had noticed during the fabulous maths lessons I was lucky enough to watch. 

So what was the turning point? 

Following this came the opportunity to begin to explore what mathematical adventures I could and would create in my classroom through concepts such as variation. I began to notice that my best most exciting lesson (for me and the children) were ones that built on small steps, making the connections required to weave together all the 3 of the curriculum’s core aims elements. Most amazingly, it created blurred lines, in the once rigid ability grouping of my classroom; every child was being treated like a mathematician and given the chance to become the ‘master’.  

I am 100% not here to dispute the place or purpose of teaching, discretely, fluency, reasoning, or problem-solving. I truly believe that mathematical fluency skills are at the heart of helping students think faster and more clearly, giving them the energy, attention, and focus to tackle complex problem-solving and reasoning questions. It is the tool the child needs to take on cognitive overload. My food for thought today is how can I/we make sure that we build a partnership in our maths lessons between our curriculum core aims and the Teaching for Mastery 5 Big Ideas… Ask yourself this: Do you, or your teachers know what they are or even better, how to use them? 

Where am I going with this?

Most importantly, I have learned to stop asking myself this:

Fluency? Reasoning? Problem-Solving? Sorry, what was the question?

…and rather than seeing these concepts as standalone question categories, view them more as types of learning experiences to hook the ‘big ideas’ onto, a place where they can come to life, often woven together… 

My advice, (for what it is worth) is:

  • Avoid viewing these curriculum core aims in isolation. Don’t let ‘problem-solving’ become a one-way ticket for your ‘clever-clogs’ or ‘gifted’ mathematicians, and certainly don’t use them as a progressive way to differentiate!
  • Definitely ask to watch a teacher-friend’s maths lesson, most importantly, use it as an opportunity to talk about the ‘maths’.
  • If you’re feeling bold enough, talk to your senior management team about TRGs.. they are brilliant and where best practice in your school (the most important place to YOU and YOUR children) really comes to life.
  • Get to know your local maths hub (if you haven’t already). To get started, click link below!
  • Finally, ask yourself this- what do your maths lesson look like?

Tags: